Ashwini Ashish Dighe vs The Union Of India Throu. The Sec. Dept Of ...

ik-161572330 Bombay High Court 11 December 2024 • WRIT PETITION NO.350 OF 2024 • 15 min read

Judges (2)

Jitendra Jain Coram M.S. Sonak Delivered

Counsel (7)

Lumiere Law Partners Firm D.P. Singh Counsel Respondent Dhruvi Shah Counsel Petitioner J. B. Mishra Counsel Respondent Kevin Gogri Counsel Petitioner Sanjeev Nair Counsel Petitioner Vikas Salgia Counsel Respondent

Parties (5)

Additional Director General of Foreign Trade Respondent Director General of Foreign Trade Respondent Joint Director General of Foreign Trade Respondent Union of India Respondent Ashwini Ashish Dighe Petitioner

Case Significance

Ashwini Ashish Dighe vs The Union Of India Throu. The Sec. Dept Of ... is a Bombay High Court decision dated December 11, 2024 (citation: ik-161572330). The petitioner, operating a telecom business in the Pune SEZ, challenged the rejection of her application for a SEZ licence and the dismissal of her appeal by the ADGFT. The court found that the rejection order was not a speaking order, failing to specify why co-relation could not be established between the items. The court quashed both the rejection letter and the appeal order, remanding the matter to the JDGFT for fresh consideration with a direction to pass a speaking order by 31 March 202 The bench comprised Justices Jitendra Jain and M.S. Sonak. The judgment was delivered by Justice M.S. Sonak. Counsel appearing: D.P. Singh (counsel for respondent), Dhruvi Shah (counsel for petitioner), J. B. Mishra (counsel for respondent), Kevin Gogri (counsel for petitioner), Sanjeev Nair (counsel for petitioner), Vikas Salgia (counsel for respondent).

Summary

The petitioner, operating a telecom business in the Pune SEZ, challenged the rejection of her application for a SEZ licence and the dismissal of her appeal by the ADGFT. The court found that the rejection order was not a speaking order, failing to specify why co-relation could not be established between the items. The court quashed both the rejection letter and the appeal order, remanding the matter to the JDGFT for fresh consideration with a direction to pass a speaking order by 31 March 2025.

What was the outcome of Ashwini Ashish Dighe vs The Union Of India Throu. The Sec. Dept Of ...?

The petitioner, operating a telecom business in the Pune SEZ, challenged the rejection of her application for a SEZ licence and the dismissal of her appeal by the ADGFT. The court found that the rejec...

Judgment

Read the full judgment on the official India Courts portal.

Read on Indian Kanoon

Source: Indian Kanoon (ik-161572330)