Manglorian Garden Homes ... vs 1A. Mrs. Maria Norton And Ors

ik-150116667 Bombay High Court 23 December 2025 • WRIT PETITION NO. 6071 OF 1995; WRIT PETITION NO. 6067 OF 1995; WRIT PETITION NO. 6137 OF 1995 • 28 min read

Judges (1)

M.M. Sathaye Delivered

Parties (7)

Manglorian Garden Homes Co-operative Housing Society Limited Petitioner H.S. Sama Respondent Hanif J. Sama Respondent Jan Mohammed S. Sama Respondent Maria Norton Respondent Noorbanu J. Sama Respondent Sameer J. Sama Respondent

Case Significance

Manglorian Garden Homes ... vs 1A. Mrs. Maria Norton And Ors is a Bombay High Court decision dated December 23, 2025 (citation: ik-150116667). Three connected writ petitions by a Bandra cooperative housing society challenging the appellate court's reversal of eviction decrees against occupants of Hill Road premises. The High Court found the appellate court erred in its assessment of sub-tenancy evidence, holding that the trial court had properly appreciated the evidence. The writ petitions were allowed, the appellate court's order was quashed, and the trial court's eviction decrees were confirmed with six weeks' time to vacate. The case was heard by Justice M.M. Sathaye.

Summary

Three connected writ petitions by a Bandra cooperative housing society challenging the appellate court's reversal of eviction decrees against occupants of Hill Road premises. The High Court found the appellate court erred in its assessment of sub-tenancy evidence, holding that the trial court had properly appreciated the evidence. The writ petitions were allowed, the appellate court's order was quashed, and the trial court's eviction decrees were confirmed with six weeks' time to vacate.

What was the outcome of Manglorian Garden Homes ... vs 1A. Mrs. Maria Norton And Ors?

Judgment

Read the full judgment on the official India Courts portal.

Read on Indian Kanoon

Source: Indian Kanoon (ik-150116667)